As the film studio was casting for Toy Story, children were asked to bring one plaything to the audition. Seven-year-old John Morris showed up with 20: a case of his cherished X-Men action figures. He landed the part.
The First Voice
Playing Andy, a young boy whose toys include cowboy Woody and astronaut Buzz Lightyear, his was the first voice ever heard in a full-length Pixar animation. Toy Story was released 30 years ago on Saturday, but to Morris the memory of its debut is as fresh as ever.
“I still have chills thinking about it because it started and then there’s Andy, and everyone turned to look at me and I was like, ‘Oh my gosh, here we go,’” the 41 year old voice actor says by phone from San Francisco. “I couldn’t believe what we were watching because it was groundbreaking. I grew up watching animation – Disney on VHS with my younger sibling – and it looked and felt new and different.”
A Cinematic Revolution
Toy Story was one of the most influential films in modern cinema. Directed by John Lasseter and produced by Pixar with distribution through Disney, it was the first fully computer-animated movie, leading studios worldwide to shift away from hand-drawn animation.
The story features toys who spring to life when humans are not present, notably Woody (Tom Hanks), a pull-string cowboy doll, and Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen), a flashy new space-ranger who threatens Woody’s status as Andy’s preferred. Their rivalry turns into camaraderie as they try to return with their owner after getting lost in the wider world.
Evolution of the Story
The premise grew out of Tin Toy (1988), a short film that won a first Oscar for Pixar in the days when it was part of a hardware company run by Apple’s Steve Jobs. Disney contacted Pixar to produce a computer-animated feature film told from a small toy’s perspective.
The original story followed the dynamic between Tinny, the mechanical one-man band toy from Tin Toy, and a puppet named Dummy. Christine Freeman, who is Pixar’s original historian, says: “The idea was of a partner movie, which hadn’t been done in animation before, and so they had these two characters and it was intriguing but it wasn’t working.
“We were fortunate that we got good feedback from the folks at Walt Disney. They said, we don’t believe that this tin toy is going to be an eight-year-old’s preferred toy and also that other guy? He’s really unpleasant. One of the amazing animators and artists who worked on Toy Story was a guy named Bud Luckey. He said, could this ventriloquist’s dummy be a cowboy? That is how Woody was created out of this Dummy character.”
Production Challenges
Tinny would transform into Buzz Lightyear, but even then the path took many turns before reaching its original destination. Asked about the 30th anniversary during a recent episode of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on CBS, Hanks replied: “Actually, it was more than 30 years, because Tim Allen and I and everybody involved in it, we recorded a Toy Story movie, for about 80 minutes of it, that was completely scrapped. We had the storyboards, the whole bit.
“The people who were managing the studio – not Pixar, Pixar people are great – the people running the studio said, ‘Look, it’s a cartoon. Let’s make them wisecrack-y. Let’s let them improv and tease each other and come up with goofy things,’ which we sort of did for a while. And they showed it, and quite frankly, it didn’t work. It wasn’t Toy Story. It wasn’t what Pixar was going for.”
Hanks, 69, added: “John [Lasseter] called up and he said, ‘We looked at it and it’s just not working, and we would like to start all over from scratch.’ We had been working on the movie for about two years. So then we began the journey all over again, which is about a two and a half to three year process, which is why on the titles on the Toy Story movies, they always say Production Babies.”
High Stakes
The stakes were high for Pixar to take its time and get it right. The company had been through various iterations as a hardware company, software company and producer of TV commercials but was struggling to make ends meet.
David A Price, author of The Pixar Touch: The Making of a Company, says from Richmond, Virginia: “If Toy Story hadn’t been a success, Pixar, I’m quite certain, wouldn’t have been able to continue for long as a company.
“First of all, Pixar was in very tight, serious financial circumstances in 1995 when the movie came out. Steve Jobs had been putting money into the company for 10 years at this point, $50m cumulatively over the years. When they needed to make salaries, as often as not the top executives would be coming to Steve Jobs hat in hand, asking them to write their cheque. Without Toy Story, there wasn’t an clear way forward for the company as a viable business.”
Legitimizing Computer Animation
Secondly, it was a make-or-break moment for the new medium. Price adds: “It was necessary for Toy Story to be a success simply to legitimise computer animation. It’s hard to appreciate now but, at that time, computer animation was more of a novelty than anything.
“It was a real question whether computer graphics would turn out to be appealing to mass audiences and if Toy Story had been a failure, then certainly the people who finance movies would have very likely stayed away from it as a medium. On the other hand, because Pixar was successful, it did spur tremendous interest in computer animation and a golden age of computer animated movies.”
Winning Formula
Toy Story’s animators had the key realization of rooting the film in a familiar world that audiences could relate to, with virtual cameras that functioned like real ones. The winning formula also included a clever screenplay, perfectly cast actors and Randy Newman’s song You’ve Got a Friend in Me.
Asked about Toy Story’s success, Price reflects: “The easy answer is, well, it’s all nostalgia. Parents 30 years ago when they were young watched the movie and now they’re bringing their kids into it. But it’s much more than that. In my opinion, the timeless elements of movie greatness are part of the story.
“Not only did they fuse new technology with old elements but it was rooted in a category that was popular at the time – or had recently been popular – and that is the buddy comedy. In the 80s, you had 48 Hours, Lethal Weapon, movies like that where very different characters start out not liking each other, circumstances force them to work together, they grow to respect each other. Toy Story was intentionally written very much in that style. This made it more attractive then and now.”
Multi-Generational Appeal
Beyond that, he argues, Toy Story works on different layers for both children and parents. “Friendship is something that’s very important to children and friendship is a key element in the story, something that the children connect with. But then for parents it’s a powerful depiction of status anxiety. On one level you have the children’s problems, on the other level of the movie you have adult problems being addressed and so it’s a movie that brings the age groups together in a powerful way.”
I got ready for the role by playing in my bedroom, basically, and using my creativity and my inventiveness
Organic Audition
The part of Andy came naturally to Morris, who grew up creating imaginary worlds via X-Men action figures, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Lego and Sylvanian Families. He recalls: “I guess my Woody equivalent would be this bear that I still have called Sunny Bear. That was my first favourite object and then I did have that experience during the holidays of getting new toys and the thrill around that, similar to Buzz.”
When he was six, Morris took an acting class called Kids on Camera in San Francisco and landed an agent. He started work as a child actor, appearing in commercials. Toy Story was his first voiceover tryout.
“I was very young, very young, and they asked us to bring our favorite toy to the audition and I brought all my X-Men action figures in a case. My mom was even like, ‘I think this is too many toys’. I was like, ‘No, I have to bring them all. I can’t just bring Storm. I have to bring Professor X and Wolverine and all the rest of them.’
“I started interacting with them and creating the voices and then later, of course, that’s how we see Andy play. I prepared for the role by playing in my room, essentially, and using my imagination and my creativity.”
Voiceover Challenges
That was invaluable for recording the role of Andy without the kind of cues that a stage actor or live action actor might expect. “They give you what they can in terms of visual guides and character drawings and renderings and little models and such, but you have to use your imagination. That’s key to voiceover.
“I teach voiceover now and that’s something I talk about a lot: fill your imagination with visuals because that’s what you have to draw from, especially when you just have a script in front of you in black and white. But I remember the first time seeing Andy early in the process and thinking, oh, he looks really nice and warm and then that did help me: OK, I’m going to try to bring a warmth to his voice.”
Secret Project
Morris fitted production around school, leaving quietly for solo recording sessions that did not involve other cast members. “I couldn’t talk about it while I was working on it. It can be hard for a kid to keep a secret like that. I would leave quietly, I guess like kids leave for doctor’s appointments or whatever.
“I said I was working on a assignment, working on a movie, but I didn’t say what it was. But then when it came out there was a lot of enthusiasm and some disbelief. Even to this day, people are like, ‘You’re kidding?’ I’m like, ‘No, I’m not kidding.’ Or people are like, ‘Is it true?’ ‘Yeah, it’s true.’”
Unprecedented Success
It was a children’s film that somehow captivated adults and a machine generated creation that somehow was as big-hearted as a Dickens novel. Made for roughly $30m, it grossed $401m worldwide, becoming one of the biggest hits of 1995. Morris, who was 11 at the time of its release, was as amazed as anyone by its success.
How does he explain it? “At the core of it is friendship and the ‘You’ve got a friend in me’ notion and the fact that the toys to Andy, and then later to Bonnie, are like friends. They’re almost person-like in the way that they are and the way that we interact with them. They’re so relatable and endearing.
“It was the first computer generated animated film so it has a place in film history, too. I have to say I’ve never met someone who doesn’t like Toy Story and hasn’t seen it. Everyone’s seen it and everyone loves it. I’m so honoured to be part of it, so grateful. I got to bring Andy to life: I mean, how amazing!”
What’s Next
Morris returned in 1999 for Toy Story 2 and in 2010 for Toy Story 3, which climaxes with a college-bound Andy donating his toys to a girl called Bonnie; Woody watches Andy leave and says softly, “So long … partner,” a scene about the emotional passage of time that reduced many a grown parent to a blubbering wreck.
Toy Story 4 appeared in 2019 and Toy Story 5 is due for release next June. Morris would be happy to return to the franchise some day. “I hear from a lot of viewers that they’re interested about Andy. What did he study in college? Does he have kids? Is he married? I’m like, well, what do you think? It’s open.
“As we know, the story can go in any number of directions. A lot of fans tell me that would bring the whole thing complete the journey if Andy was an adult and he has kids; maybe he has Andy Jr and maybe Bonnie babysits them and maybe